Handmade in Richmond, Indiana Free U.S. shipping on orders $99+ Built to roll. See the proof

How to Design Balanced D&D Homebrew Races and Classes

2014 fifth-edition design references with a separately identified 2024 compatibility section; use the chosen rules version consistently.

From the Crit Hit Ceramics editorial team. See our editorial standards for sourcing, corrections, and assisted-drafting practices.

Rules edition: This guide explains homebrew design using the 2014 fifth-edition character options as its main design reference. It identifies the relevant 2024 terminology and character-creation changes separately. Do not treat a 2014 design example as a rules formula for a 2024 option.

Designing a homebrew race, species, or class is a substantial rules project. Start with the play experience you want, compare the idea with options from the same rules version, and test a limited draft with the group. There is no official point-value chart that can guarantee a new option is balanced.

Set the rules version and design goal

Write down the campaign’s rules baseline before drafting. The 2014 Player’s Handbook calls a character’s ancestry a race; the 2024 rules use species and place ability-score increases in the character’s background rather than in the species. Both books provide their own class tables and progression. Mixing a trait, progression, or optional rule from another source can create interactions the original design did not account for.

State the concept in one sentence: what should this option let a character do, and what makes it different from an existing choice? Before inventing mechanics, check whether the same fantasy can be achieved by choosing an existing option, using an optional rule your DM allows, or changing only the description while keeping the mechanics unchanged. A reskin is often easier to review than a new feature.

Designing a 2014 race

The 2014 Dungeon Master’s Guide includes guidance for creating new character options, and the 2014 Player’s Handbook supplies the races and traits that form the comparison set. Use those sources together. Do not assume every race follows one fixed template: traits vary, and optional rules or later books can change how an option is presented.

Review the package as a whole. Consider its ability-score rules, size and speed, senses, proficiencies, defenses, movement, spells, and active features. Ask when each feature can be used, what action or resource it costs, how often it returns, and how it interacts with common class features. A trait that adds an attack, grants flight, changes a saving throw, or prevents a condition cannot be judged only by assigning it an invented number of “balance points.” Its impact depends on the rest of the character and the campaign.

Use examples from the same 2014 source set and compare like with like. If the campaign uses an optional ability-score rule from a later 2014 supplement, label that choice and apply it consistently; do not present the optional rule as part of every 2014 character. Write the trait so a player and DM can tell exactly when it works and what limits it has.

Designing a class

A full class is more complex than a single ancestry option: it must function across its level progression and interact with the game’s combat, exploration, and social tools. First consider whether a subclass, background, feat, spell, or reskin would serve the concept with less new machinery.

If a new class is still the best fit, map its progression using the chosen edition’s class tables. Review its features at every level, including its subclass choices, ability-score improvements or feats, spell progression if any, and resource limits. Class features do not all arrive at the same levels, so avoid rules of thumb that claim every class follows identical “power spike” levels.

Check action and resource interactions. Can a feature be used every turn, or does it spend a limited resource? Does it compete for an action, bonus action, or reaction? What happens if the character multiclasses? Does a feature scale with class level, total character level, or another value? Compare the draft with published classes that serve a similar role at the same levels, and test edge cases instead of assuming that a familiar hit die or recharge schedule makes the whole class balanced.

Keep 2014 and 2024 guidance distinct

In the 2024 rules, a species provides traits such as creature type, size, Speed, and special traits; a background determines the character’s ability-score increases and Origin feat. The 2024 Dungeon Master’s Guide also has its own design tools, including guidance for creating backgrounds, creatures, magic items, and spells. Those procedures are version-specific and are not a universal scoring system for designing a species or class.

If you adapt an older race or class for a 2024 campaign, use the 2024 rules for older options and the group’s chosen source text. When using an older race option for 2024 character creation, ignore the ability-score increases printed for that option and use the chosen background’s ability-score adjustments instead. Mark any new mechanic as homebrew, note which edition it is intended for, and have the DM approve the conversion before play.

Playtest with the whole group

Share the complete draft before anyone builds a character around it. Agree that the first version is provisional, how feedback will be collected, and how revisions will be handled. Test the option in situations where its signature features matter and where they do not. Ask whether the feature met its goal, whether it overshadowed another character, whether its wording caused disputes, and whether it added enjoyable choices without slowing play.

Keep notes on actual use, then change one part at a time where practical. A feature may be too strong only in a particular combination, or may rarely matter despite sounding powerful. Explain revisions to affected players and preserve the character’s story where possible. If the option still does not work for the campaign, replace it with an existing choice or retire it by prior agreement.

For the table’s approval, trial, and revision process, see our guide to evaluating homebrew at the table.

Official rules sources

Join the party

New drops. Rare runs. No spam.

Be first in line when a new batch leaves the kiln.